Are Scored Brake Discs Dangerous?

This post contains affiliate links. Read the full disclosure here.

The brake disc also loses material over time and gets thinner with each usage, just like the pads do. How long you can let something persist before replacing it is the real concern. Since various variables may cause it to be extended or shortened, you cannot rely on the expiration date. 

So, are scored brake discs dangerous? yes, they are, and do not let anyone tell you differently, especially if this information is not coming from the brake disc manufacturer.

However, some people don’t give a damn about this information and are content to continue driving with a brake disc that may eventually stop working altogether. Hopefully, they will be able to tell how they avoided a potentially terrible accident while still alive.

The thinness of the brake disc raises a number of problems. The installation of a new brake pad without replacing the scored brake disc is one of the problems that have been brought up frequently, especially on automobile internet forums.

Compared to the brake disc, brake pads are less expensive and hence simpler to replace. Therefore, as the brake disc becomes scored, the braking performance declines. As a result, people with limited financial resources may consider installing new brake pads in the hopes that the brake performance would be improved. 

This article will discuss the safety of this method of fitting brake pads and whether it has an impact on how quickly they wear.

Additionally, we’ll go over how long a brake disc should be used before it has to be replaced, how to recognize a brake disc that has been severely scored, how to slow down the rate of scoring, and how dangerous it is to continue driving with that kind of brake disc.

Trending Searches

Table Of Contents

How dangerous is it to drive a car that has a scored brake disc?

The risk of operating a vehicle with a scored brake disc increases with the degree of brake disc wear. Depending on the quality of the brake disc and other related variables, all brake discs gradually deteriorate and develop scoring over time. However, not all scored brake discs are dangerous to drive on.

The braking disc’s thickness is crucial. Instead of trying to prolong their life by adding new brake pads, brakes that are too thin can no longer be used for driving and should be replaced.

Disregard the assertion made by individuals who contend that scored brake discs may be safer than non-scored brake discs. Consider your driving frequency, the anticipated lifespan of the car part under ideal conditions, and your previous history of car part replacement when creating a budget for your vehicle’s maintenance.

By doing so, you may predict when it is almost time to replace some automotive parts and avoid having to wait until symptoms appear. Some auto parts are “silent killers,” meaning that degradation may not become visibly apparent until it has advanced significantly.

No manufacturer leaves it up to the driver or car owner to choose the brake disc thickness that is safe for driving. Instead, every manufacturer of brake discs has established the minimum thickness below which the disc should be changed. Therefore, when this mark is reached, you are no longer allowed to drive the brake disc or it becomes extremely unsafe to do so.

As soon as the new brake disc is put to use, its journey of getting worn out commences almost immediately. This is only a natural process and happens to all brake discs irrespective of the quality or company reputation. However, taking your time to learn what the manufacturer’s guideline is, in terms of the minimum thickness for the brake disc will save you from placing your life in danger.

In determining whether or not it is safe to keep driving with your current brake disc, you must also consider how long the current disc has been in use and how frequently the car is driven in a month or year.

For a car that you rarely skip a day without driving or that which is driven for a really long distance every week or thereabout, the brake disc should be examined and if need be, changed by the end of the year.

If the disc thickness is not accurately measured and compared to the manufacturer’s recommendations, even mechanics may differ on the braking disc. A face-value analysis may lead your car’s mechanic to the conclusion that the brake disc is too thin and needs to be changed or that it cannot be resurfaced.

To extend the useful lifespan of the brake pad, the contact surface of the brake disc may need to be resurfaced or rotated. Because brake discs that are too thin cannot be spun, mechanics must determine whether the disc is suitable for this by examining the thickness of the pad.

It is best to follow the manufacturer’s directions in this scenario. To keep the brake disc from failing suddenly, drive on a flat, empty route and apply the brakes while watching the braking performance. You can also give the auto repair shop permission to carry out a similar automated test to evaluate the brake’s efficacy.

When you’re braking hard while traveling downhill in the rain, that’s when your brake discs are put to the real test. The decision to continue using the damaged brake disc while driving will then become clear to you. Both damaged brake discs and worn-out tires are unworthy since they both enhance risk.

Why does the brake disc require replacement?

The dispute over the brake disc is particularly compelling among people who are not familiar with the basic physics governing the braking system. This set of motorists or car owners are reluctant to replace the brake disc because they think that because the brake disc is made of metal rather than rubber, it will never wear out.

I know what you’re thinking: if they could only look at the brake disc, they would see that it suffers the same fate as the pads. The brake disc still experiences breaks, cracks, and wear-and-tear in addition to scoring from friction and heat cycles and may require more frequent replacement of the brake pads.

Different brake disc thicknesses are advised for the front and back. Regardless of the manufacturer’s recommendations, if the sides are more than 1mm worn, the front brake disc should frequently be replaced. The rear brake disc’s 0.75mm of wear shows that upkeep is necessary.

The brake disc’s ability to hold heat decreases noticeably with time. The disc will undergo a variety of changes as a result of further heat exposure, including deterioration, cracking, and loss of firmness.

Trust me when I say you do not want to find out what will happen when you are adamant about changing the brake disc. It is best never to have to find out what this could do to you.

How can you tell when the brake disc has to be replaced?

Keep an eye out for a few obvious signs if you believe your brake disc may be damaged. These include:

A distant resting place

The stopping distance shows the condition of the braking disc and brake pads. This is highly appreciated when the brakes are applied in an emergency and a quick, unrestricted braking reaction is required. In this case, a brake system with a worn brake disc may require extra time to stop the car.

A screeching noise

This is another indication of the commonality between a scored brake disc and worn brake pads. To identify which brake part has to be changed, each must be carefully inspected. One of the first obvious signs of a worn-out brake disc or pad is often the noise.

brake pads that squeal

When the foot is on the brake pedal and it sounds like the brake pedal is rattling underneath the foot, it may be time to make a quick trip to the auto shop to get your brake disc checked out. In circumstances like steep hills, which are tougher on the brakes, a quick stop could keep you from losing control of the car.


It is patently false to claim that your brake disc has to be replaced since it is made of metal, the car is not a race car, or the driver drives cautiously without inadvertently applying the brakes if there are fractures in the brake disc.

How many miles will it take to wear out the brake disc?

I hate to put a number on it, but the majority will typically survive between 50,000 and 100,000 kilometers in excellent conditions. This is an extremely fluid range that depends on numerous factors.

How can this longevity be altered? 

It turns out that you do have a significant impact on the lifespan of the brake disc. Regular cleaning, cautious braking, and other behaviors can have a significant impact on the brake disc’s longevity.

Are Scored Brake Discs Dangerous – Conclusion

The brake discs do eventually wear down, and after that point, it becomes dangerous to keep driving. To increase the lifespan of the brake discs, refrain from riding the brakes and carry out other maintenance operations.

Leave a Reply